Introduction

Public colleges and universities have long been a cornerstone of American education, drawing students and scholars from around the world. Today, that system is under pressure. Lawmakers and governing boards in states ranging from Kansas to Utah are demanding evidence that professors earn their salaries and job protections. Faculty members push back, describing grueling schedules, shrinking departments, and pay that has failed to keep up with rising costs. The debate touches on tenure, workload expectations, and the public's fading confidence in higher education.

What Happened

Across several states, legislators and university boards have moved to tighten oversight of faculty. In Kansas, the Board of Regents adopted a policy in January that sets specific ranges for teaching, research, and service duties. Professors at the state's research universities must spend 40% to 55% of their time on instruction, 35% to 45% on research, and 5% to 20% on public service. Regional universities face even higher teaching expectations, between 60% and 75%. Every faculty member must now submit a written work plan, undergo annual reviews, and face a comprehensive peer evaluation every five years instead of seven. Tenured professors who receive two consecutive unsatisfactory reviews risk dismissal, reassignment, or an extended improvement plan.

Similar efforts are underway in Wisconsin, Utah, and Ohio, where officials have introduced minimum teaching loads and more rigorous post-tenure evaluations. Supporters argue these measures protect taxpayer investment. Faculty leaders counter that the policies rest on a mistaken belief that academics coast after earning tenure.

Why This Matters

Public trust in higher education has eroded significantly. Gallup data shows that 38% of Americans expressed a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in colleges and universities in 2026, compared with 57% in 2015. Meanwhile, the share with very little or no confidence climbed from 10% to 25%. Skepticism about degree value, rising tuition, and campus politics has fueled doubts about tenure, which was originally created to protect academic freedom.

The strain is not limited to politically conservative states. In Massachusetts, free community college has driven enrollment up by more than 43% since 2022, adding roughly 27,000 students and increasing pressure on instructors. At the same time, faculty pay is losing ground to inflation. Average full-time faculty salaries rose 2.3% from fall 2024 to fall 2025, but inflation ran at 2.7%, leaving inflation-adjusted pay about 9.5% below 2019 levels, according to the AAUP.

Key Takeaways

  • Many professors report working roughly 55 hours per week, even though standard contracts often specify 40 hours during the academic year.
  • Tenure-track and tenured positions are becoming rarer; nationally, about 32% of faculty held such appointments in fall 2023, down from roughly 53% in 1987.
  • Kansas now requires written work plans, annual reviews, and five-year peer evaluations for tenured faculty, with consequences for repeated unsatisfactory ratings.
  • A Utah legislative audit found that only eight out of 666 tenured-faculty reviews identified teaching deficiencies, raising questions about leadership and accountability structures.
  • Faculty say departments have lost significant numbers of tenured colleagues, leaving remaining professors to absorb more advising, committee work, and student support duties.

Conclusion

The confrontation over faculty workloads reflects a broader struggle over the purpose and funding of public higher education. While some lawmakers view stricter accountability as necessary stewardship, professors describe an unsustainable environment marked by heavier responsibilities, fewer colleagues, and stagnant real wages. Rebuilding public confidence and institutional capacity will likely take years, and there is no quick policy fix. For many educators, the core issue remains the same: they want to teach and support students, but they say current conditions make that mission increasingly difficult.