Introduction
For more than two decades, Russia's richest businessmen have learned that speaking out against Vladimir Putin can carry a steep personal cost. Yet behind closed doors, some members of the country's ultra-wealthy elite are now quietly asking what happens when the current president eventually leaves the Kremlin. A recent analysis from BBC Monitoring suggests that a subtle but meaningful shift is underway in how Russia's mega-rich view the nation's future.
What Happened
Hours after Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022, Putin summoned more than three dozen of the country's wealthiest men to the Kremlin's Yekaterininsky Hall. The attendees wore face masks and appeared tired, while Putin sat at the opposite end of the room without one. In remarks captured on Kremlin video, he used coded language to ask for their backing of the war effort and the economy. None of the billionaires present spoke up.
That silence reflects a long-standing dynamic. In 2003, Mikhail Khodorkovsky, then Russia's richest man, was imprisoned after criticizing the president and funding opposition groups. He served a decade on charges of tax evasion, fraud, and embezzlement, which he denied. His case served as a warning to other tycoons.
Since the war began, the Kremlin has maintained control through a mix of rewards and punishments. Critics have seen assets seized, while loyalists have received lucrative state contracts. According to Forbes, Russia now has 155 billionaires with combined wealth approaching $700 billion, yet many say their money no longer buys political influence.
Why This Matters
The war and Western sanctions have left many Russian tycoons feeling isolated. They face restrictions on private jets and superyachts in Europe, and some describe their treatment abroad as humiliating. At home, their fortunes are often tied to state contracts or presidential goodwill, leaving them vulnerable to sudden losses.
Observers note a change in tone. Where tycoons once used respectful nicknames for Putin, some now refer to him with a dismissive term meaning "oldie" or "granddad." Analysts say this signals declining reverence, even if open dissent remains rare.
A rare public signal came earlier this year when Andrey Melnichenko, a fertiliser magnate and one of Russia's richest men, gave an interview to The Economist. While he repeated some Kremlin talking points, he also called for an end to one-man rule and greater engagement with the world. Some analysts believe the interview may have received tacit approval from authorities, though the motives remain unclear.
Key Takeaways
- Russia's ultra-wealthy are privately discussing a future after Vladimir Putin.
- Public silence persists because criticizing the president has historically led to prison or asset seizures.
- Western sanctions and the war in Ukraine have reduced the tycoons' freedom and influence abroad.
- Possible post-Putin scenarios include democracy, continued autocracy, or a return to 1990s-style oligarchic rule.
- Most observers believe the tycoons are unlikely to act while Putin is still in power.
Conclusion
Russia's richest men once pulled strings at the highest levels of government. If Putin departs, many are expected to attempt to regain that influence. Whether the structures left behind by the current administration would permit such a comeback remains an open question. For now, fear and financial dependence keep most of the country's mega-rich on the sidelines, waiting and watching.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.