Introduction
A major independent review into youth unemployment is set to recommend that the government gradually reduce National Insurance contributions for employers who hire young workers. Former Labour minister Alan Milburn’s report, which has been in development for a year, proposes a phased approach targeting people aged 21 to 24, with an initial focus on retail and hospitality. The review also addresses the wider benefits system and the growing number of young people classified as not in employment, education or training.
What Happened
According to the forthcoming report, businesses should see the threshold at which they begin paying National Insurance for 21 to 24-year-olds doubled from £5,000 to £10,000. Milburn is expected to advise that this reduction take place over five years and only proceed when fiscal conditions permit. The Resolution Foundation has estimated that an immediate, across-the-board cut would cost approximately £5.1 billion.
The review also calls for changes to welfare support. It suggests that under-25s should no longer be eligible for the health component of Universal Credit or personal independence payments, the primary disability benefit in England and Wales. Instead, Milburn wants a legal guarantee offering a job, training, or employment support, with the possibility of benefit sanctions for those who decline assistance.
Why This Matters
Official figures show nearly one million people aged 16 to 24 are currently not in employment, education or training. The government spends an estimated £22 billion annually supporting young people who are economically inactive. Milburn argues that investing in skills is ineffective if there are no available jobs, and that employers—particularly small businesses—face significant costs when hiring young workers who may need additional support for mental health or other challenges.
The report enters a broader political debate about employment taxes. Chancellor John Healey recently raised employer National Insurance, while the opposition has called for those costs to be halved. At the same time, the Work and Pensions Secretary has announced an expansion of a subsidised jobs scheme for young people claiming Universal Credit.
Key Takeaways
- Alan Milburn’s independent review recommends a gradual reduction in employer National Insurance for workers aged 21 to 24.
- The NI threshold for this age group would double from £5,000 to £10,000, phased in over five years starting with retail and hospitality.
- The report proposes restricting access to certain health-related benefits for under-25s and introducing a job or training guarantee.
- Nearly one million young people in the UK are classified as Neets, with annual government support costs estimated at £22 billion.
- An immediate National Insurance cut would cost around £5.1 billion, according to the Resolution Foundation.
- Small business owners have described current employment costs as unsustainable, with some unable to take on apprentices despite high demand from young job seekers.
Conclusion
Milburn’s report is expected to land at a time of intense scrutiny over public finances and welfare policy. While the proposals aim to reduce youth unemployment and ease pressure on employers, they also suggest tighter conditions for benefit claimants. Whether the government adopts the recommendations will depend on fiscal space and political appetite for what is likely to be a contested debate over the future of work and support for young people.

Discussion
Join the conversation
Thoughtful reactions, questions, and follow-up ideas help shape the next story.